fbpx

Media Summary

Canadian court rule Iran intentionally shot down passenger flight

[ssba]

The UK media covers the announcement of a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas. BBC News, The Financial Times, The Telegraph, The Guardian and The Times report that the ceasefire came into effect after 11 days of fighting that saw more than 240 people killed, most of them in Gaza. The papers note that international pressure, specifically from the US, pushed the parties to a ceasefire. The Independent reports that the UN and several NGOs warned that Gaza’s severely damaged infrastructure would take years to rebuild. Health, education, water, and energy facilities have been damaged.

The Associated Press reports that Palestinians have claimed victory following the ceasefire agreement. The report notes that thousands took to the street at 2am, when the ceasefire came into effect. People were seen waiving Palestinian and Hamas flags, honking car horns and setting off fireworks.

Josie Ensor writes in The Telegraph that history shows us this ceasefire may be short lived. She writes: “The only chance the new ceasefire has of holding is for both sides to be reminded of what is at stake if it doesn’t. For Israel, which is now forced to deal with a much less friendly US administration than it was previously under Donald Trump, they have been raised … the only way to break the holding pattern, Gazans say, is to end the Strip’s isolation. That would involve opening up borders and allowing free travel, the return of the displaced to Jerusalem and other Palestinian territories, and full statehood – demands Israel is unlikely to ever agree on unless there is a complete and utter rethinking of US support.”

Jake Wallis Simons writes in The Spectator about how Israel’s 11-day operation in Gaza demolished Hamas’ operation. He writes: “Intelligence sources report that factions inside Hamas are already grumbling about the reckless decision to invite so much destruction upon Gaza. The years leading up to the war were generally characterised by calm, with Israel investing heavily in infrastructure in the Strip. All this now lies in ruins. This week, Hamas fired mortars at an aid convoy attempting to enter the territory from Israel. As a symbol, it was both poignant and perfect. Hamas may have won the propaganda war, but Israelis have a better chance at living.”

The Times reports a Canadian court has ruled that the downing of Ukrainian Airlines flight 752 was an intentional act of terrorism. Two Iranian missiles shot down the passenger flight last January amid heightened tensions after the assassination of Iranian commander Qassem Soleimani. The Canadian judge said that “on a balance of probabilities the missile attacks on Flight 752 were intentional. The plaintiffs have established that the shooting down of Flight 752 was an act of terrorism and constitutes ‘terrorist activity’”.

The Economist reports on navigational challenges that vessels could encounter passing through the Strait of Hormuz as Iran releases counterfeit signals, sending boats miles in the wrong direction, specifically into Iran’s territorial water. There is reason to believe that Iran is luring vessels into their waters to seize them. The paper notes that “for Iran, spoofing is a cheap way of riling Western powers and giving itself leverage in international affairs”.

Reflecting on the ceasefire, Yossi Yehoshua in Yediot Ahronot compares the situation with Hezbollah, that has “been deterred and has not initiated hostilities since 2006, yet since then it has turned into a monster and its rocket arsenal has grown from 30,000 to 150,000. The rockets are heavier, more accurate, and have a longer range, and Hezbollah can fire 2,000 of them per day, which is why it’s pretty clear nowadays that Israel has been deterred too … why does that matter? Because basking in quiet without dealing with Hamas’s military build-up is not a success. On the contrary: it’s a failure. In such a situation, the right thing for the IDF to do is to continue attacking the means of weapons production, similarly to the campaign-between-the-wars that Israel has been waging against the Iranian’s efforts to entrench themselves in Syria and to establish a second Hezbollah there …  and if they want genuine reconstruction and significant humanitarian aid, then let it only be under close Israeli supervision, in exchange for a broad course of action that will include a deal for the return of the bodies of the captive soldiers and the living missing civilians, at a price that does not include releasing dozens of terrorists who have blood on their hands.”

Maariv highlights the international support that Israel has received. Germany, Austria, the Czech Republic and Slovenia have all publicly raised the Israeli flag. “Another expression of support came this time within the Italian parliamentarians waving Israeli flag: ‘For a life of freedom, democracy and peace. The League Party is once again demonstrating in parliament its solidarity with Israel and its right to exist.'”

Israel Hayom covers the speech by Israeli Ambassador to the United States and the United Nations Gilad Erdan to the UN General Assembly yesterday.He is quoted saying, “Right now, as I speak to you, Israeli citizens are running to seek shelter from Hamas’ indiscriminate attacks…You are calling on Israel to exercise restraint when it is facing indiscriminate attacks every day. The hypocrisy in this institution knows no boundaries,” hitting out at Turkey, Denmark and France. Erdan further explained, “We see an attempt to create a false moral equivalence… between Israel, a democracy that seeks peace and abides by international law, and a murderous terrorist organisation with an ideology similar to ISIS… Hama’s charter, like the Nazis, is committed to the genocide of the Jewish people. Israel makes every effort to avoid civilian casualties. Hamas makes every effort to increase civilian casualties.” After PA Foreign Minister Riyad al-Maliki accused Israel of committing war crimes and deliberately massacring children in their sleep, Erdan walked out of the General Assembly meeting in protest.

Haaretz reports that Iran’s President Hassan Rouhani said an “agreement in principle has been achieved” regarding the removal of sanctions amid ongoing nuclear talks with the West. According to Rouhani, “All parties to the talks have agreed to lift all major sanctions on oil, petrochemicals, shipping, insurance, the central bank and so on.” However, senior diplomats from Britain, France and Germany (E3) offered a note of caution, saying that while there was some tangible progress with the contours of a final deal emerging, success was not guaranteed.  “There are still some very difficult issues ahead. We do not underestimate the challenges that lay before us,” they said in a statement. The E3 diplomats said it was critical that Iran let the IAEA continue its monitoring and verification work and urged them both to find a way forward. Israel Hayom adds, “The International Atomic Energy Agency faces a looming deadline with Iran over its inspections of Tehran’s nuclear sites. It reached a temporary deal with Tehran in February to ensure inspections continued, though Iran stopped allowing it to access footage recorded on cameras monitoring its nuclear sites.  Iran vowed to hold onto the footage for three months but warned it would erase it if sanctions relief didn’t come. That three-month deadline expires either Friday under the Gregorian calendar or Monday under the Persian calendar.”

Yeditot Ahronot also focuses on Yitzhak Herzog’s campaign to become President in two week’s time, noting “28 years after his father, the late sixth President Haim Herzog, left the presidential residence in Jerusalem, is the chairman of the Jewish Agency, Yitzhak (Buji) Herzog, two steps from the president’s house. After working on the campaign and succeeding in recruiting the signatures of a quarter of the Knesset members, Herzog is confident in his ability to mobilise the support of 61 MKs and defeat Miriam Peretz. Herzog has been careful to cultivate good relations with all sectors over the years. As the former chairman of the Labour Party, he has close ties to the left and the centre. As the grandson of the former Chief Rabbi of Israel, he has always been close to the ultra-Orthodox.” Furthermore, “He met with all the members of the Knesset and sent them close associates to make a confirmation of support. He called every MK to wish him a happy birthday and took an interest in everything. He’s nice to everyone.”

In Maariv, Ben Caspit provides an update from Israel’s political crisis. He writes: “The pro-change bloc has begun to teem with activity once again in the past few days. Hundreds of Yamina activists sobered up to recognize the sheer enormity of the Bibi-ists’ hypocrisy. A group of important party activists issued a public call on Bennett to form a government. Petitions have begun to be circulated. Meanwhile, Mansour Abbas has moved much closer to the pro-change bloc. He has reached understandings with Lapid, Saar and company about the composition of the Knesset communities and about planned legislation. The chances of Abbas joining forces with Netanyahu to support a bill that would allow the direct election of the prime minister is all but nonexistent.” However, Caspit writes that the one person who is preventing Bennett from joining the pro-change bloc is Ayelet Shaked, his colleague in Yamina.