Initial assessments: Early and conflicting assessments of the damage to Iran’s nuclear sites continued to colour commentary on the outcome of the Twelve Day War.
- A leaked report from the US Defence Intelligence Agency (DIA) that questioned the extent of damage was seized upon by critics of the war and prominently featured in major media outlets.
- Yesterday, at the NATO summit in the Hague, President Trump shared a summary assessment from the Israel Atomic Energy Commission stating that the Fordow site, the underground facility hit by American bunker buster bombs, was “inoperable.”
- The Washington-based Institute for Science and International Security has published an initial assessment. Based on high-resolution satellite imagery and open-source intelligence. their initial determination is that: “Overall, Israel’s and US attacks have effectively destroyed Iran’s centrifuge enrichment program. It will be a long time before Iran comes anywhere near the capability it had before the attack. That being said, there are residuals such as stocks of 60 percent, 20 percent, and 3-5 percent enriched uranium and the centrifuges manufactured but not yet installed at Natanz or Fordow. These non-destroyed parts pose a threat as they can be used in the future to produce weapon-grade uranium.”
- The Iranians themselves will be making their own assessments of the damage to their nuclear programme, something they were not able to begin in the immediate aftermath of the US raids because roads leading to the site were reportedly also bombed. Iran’s Foreign Ministry spokesman Esmail Baghaei conceded that “our nuclear installations have been badly damaged,” but did not offer more detail.
- For the time being, the IDF has not released any detailed assessment regarding the current state of Iran’s nuclear programme. Chief of General Staff Eyal Zamir did, however, make a public statement last night in which he described the damage to Iran’s nuclear programme as “not a localised blow, but a systemic one.” He added that “the accumulated achievement allows us to determine that the Iranian nuclear program suffered severe, broad, and deep damage and was pushed back by years.”
- Mossad Director David Barnea also released a video statement yesterday hailing the achievements of his agency in the war with Iran. “Israel, thanks to this entire security apparatus, today feels like a different country, a safer country, a braver country that is prepared for the future,” he said in the statement. “Objectives that once seemed imaginary have now been achieved. We will continue to keep a watchful eye on all known Iranian projects — we are intimately familiar with them — and we will be there, just as we have been until now.”
Context: Detailed damage assessments have not been made public, and will take several more weeks to compile.
- On Israel’s Channel 12 News, Zohar Palti, a former head of the Political-Military Bureau at the Ministry of Defence and previously a senior official in the Mossad, explained that a serious battle damage assessment (BDA) report takes weeks to compile, as it is built on physical and intelligence data that are impossible to attain simply by examining a satellite photo.
- Inputs will include reports from the crews carrying out the bombing, subsequent flyovers, satellite imagery, human intelligence from sources on the ground, and signal intelligence monitoring enemy assessments and recovery efforts.
- Along with Mossad operative, IDF Chief of Staff revealed on Wednesday that IDF commandos had also been operating on the ground in Iran, without going into more details.
- Along with Israel, US and Iran, it is expected that the UK and France are also likely to make their own assessments on the status of Iran’s nuclear project.
- Another unanswered question relates to the stockpiles of highly enriched uranium (HEU).
- The fact that the Americans are still making demands after the war regarding HEU in Iran is widely seen as an indication that some HEU remains in Iranian hands. There has been widespread speculation about possible Iranian efforts to remove HEU from bombed sites before they were hit, as well as competing assessments from various experts regarding their ability to convert it into bomb-grade material without the facilities that have been destroyed.
- In parallel, five funerals were held in Israel on Wednesday, and two more will be held today, for the seven IDF soldiers killed yesterday in combat in Khan Yunis, in the southern Gaza Strip.
- So far this June, 19 soldiers have been killed in action, making it the deadliest period for Israel this year.
- At the same time, though 28 civilians were killed by Iranian ballistic missiles, not a single IDF soldier was killed in action in the 12 Day War.
- In Israeli media, families of fallen soldiers as well as families of hostages still held in Gaza were widely interviewed with many urging the government to leverage the end of the war in Iran to bring about an end to the war in Gaza.
- A political firestorm erupted following the statement of MK Moshe Gafni, a senior figure in one of the ultra-orthodox parties that are part of the governing coalition (and one of the longest serving members of parliament). Gafni questioned the efficacy of continuing the war in Gaza. “I don’t understand, even to this very moment, what we are fighting for there,” he said yesterday in a Knesset committee meeting. “I don’t understand what the need is. What are we going to do there when soldiers are being killed all the time?… We need a Trump to come here and say, ‘We are bringing back the hostages, stopping all these things, and returning to normality.’” Gafni and his party have been threatening in recent weeks to leave the coalition if the Government won’t ensure the passage of a law exempting ultra-orthodox men from the draft.
- The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) reports that it has distributed 44 million meals in the four weeks it has been operating. Rev. Johnnie Moore, the former chair of the GHF, once more called on the UN to work with the Foundation, something the UN and most aid agencies have thus far refused to do. He further condemned the inaccurate reporting of violence at the GHF distribution sites, accusing Hamas of deliberately planting false stories with Al Jazeera that GHF sites were “death traps” in a deliberate attempt to sabotage the only method of aid distribution that Hamas is unable to profit from.
Looking ahead: Within a few weeks an aggregated and consensus view of the battle damage assessment (BDA) could be made public.
- Much media attention has been focussed on the question of the whereabout of Iran’s Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei. The New York Times reports that he has not been seen in public at all in more than a week, with speculation rampant about his physical and mental state. Even while the ceasefire was being brokered, the military commanders and government officials responsible for passing messages to the Qatari mediators were “evasive about whether they [had] met or spoken with Mr. Khamenei.”
- The US is now prepared to renew negotiations over a nuclear deal. Negotiations had been underway for two months before the onset of the war without any real progress. The US administration has reportedly set three conditions for an agreement now: no enrichment on Iranian soil, removal of all highly enriched uranium from Iran, and a cap on ballistic missile production.

