What’s happened: Israel is reeling with anger and disgust at the latest brutal propaganda videos released by Hamas over the weekend.
- Hamas released two videos featuring 24 year old hostage Evyatar David. The first video did not include any statements, but his physical condition, severely emaciated, appeared grim with his bones jutting out of his body.
- The second video, showed David digging his own grave on orders from his captors. “I don’t eat. There’s barely any water,” said David, which he said was recorded on July 27. “This tin is for two days so that I don’t die,” he said, showing a small tin of food to the camera.
- In a script presumably dictated by his captors he says, “I have no idea whether there’s going to be food, I haven’t the faintest idea. I haven’t eaten in I don’t know how many days in a row, and I’ve been here in very-very bad shape for a very long time already.”
- In a third video, Palestinian Islamic Jihad released footage of the 21-year-old hostage, Rom Braslavski, who appeared to be gaunt and wept in the recording. Rom said, “Just give us food, if not for the Gaza Strip, then for the hostages.”
- The videos followed the visit of US envoy Witkoff who toured Gaza on Friday to personally witness the aid delivery system and later met with hostage families and consultations with senior Israeli officials. It now appears that the “Witkoff outline” is no longer on the table. Witkoff told the families they would now work on a comprehensive deal in which all of the hostages are to be released and the war ended.
- In Beit Hanoun, in northern Gaza, the last of the Hamas fighters surrendered to troops from the Givati Brigade.
- Following questioning, the terrorists gave information about munitions warehouses adjacent to the tunnel shaft where they exited, leading troops to the warehouses. Large quantities of arms and materiel were found, including vests, rifle magazines, rifles, grenades and more. Supplies for an extended stay underground were also found in the tunnel, including food, water and hygiene supplies.
- Also over the weekend, the IDF demolished the main tunnel linking Beit Hanoun with Jabalya, Beit Lahiya and the northern reaches of Gaza City. It is estimated that dozens of Hamas terrorists were trapped in the tunnel.
- The military also said more than 130 targets were attacked around Gaza over the weekend.
- The IDF also said it had killed the terrorist Salah al-Din Za’ara, who served as the deputy commander of the Hamas Al-Furqan Battalion.
- In southern Gaza, forces killed terrorists and destroying terrorist infrastructure, including underground and buildings where terrorists operated and weapons were stored.
- Amid the ongoing fighting in Gaza, the Houthis continued to fire ballistic missiles at Israel. Sirens sounded on Friday evening in and around Jerusalem, and the Dead Sea area after a missile was fired from Yemen. The missile was intercepted by the Arrow 3 system. On Sunday the IDF intercepted a drone close to the Israeli – Egyptian border that was also launched from Yemen.
Context: Although hostage negotiations have not formally broken down, the sense in Israel is that there is currently no deal on the horizon, after Hamas hardened their negotiating positions coinciding with the British government and others increasing their pressure on Israel.
- It is now understood that Prime Minister Netanyahu is working with President Trump and his team to draft a comprehensive new proposal that includes a deal to release all the remaining hostages and presumably end the war.
- The new proposal reportedly includes demands for the release of all remaining hostages in a single group and for Hamas to disarm. On the day after in Gaza, a US-led international administration is to be established in the Gaza Strip.
- If Hamas do not agree the US is expected to give Israel a free hand to operate militarily in the Gaza Strip.
- The horrific video footage of Evyatar David and Rom Braslavski is seen as proof that Hamas is deliberately starving the hostages in order to ratchet up pressure on Israel.
- Israel now believes the dire humanitarian situation in the Strip actually helps Hamas, and has allowed a surge in the flow of humanitarian aid.
- According to the latest data from COGAT, in the past week over 23,000 tons of humanitarian entered Gaza and 1,200 trucks were successfully collected by the UN and international organisations.
- In addition, hundreds of pallets of humanitarian supplies were airdropped by international partners to help address urgent needs on the ground. In cooperation with Israel, the UAE, Jordan, Egypt, France, Germany, and Belgium facilitated 136 aid packages, containing food airdropped into Gaza.
- Addressing Hamas’s campaign of starvation, IDF Chief of Staff Zamir, said “The current campaign of false accusations of intentional starvation is a deliberate, timed, and deceitful attempt to accuse the IDF, a moral army, of war crimes. The ones responsible for the killing and suffering of the residents in the Gaza Strip is Hamas. IDF soldiers and commanders act with integrity and morality, in accordance with the IDF’s values and international law.”
- Separately, a group of countries including Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Jordan and Qatar presented a document to the UN demanding that Hamas be disarmed and excluded from future governance of the Gaza Strip. The document represents welcome pressure now being applied on Hamas, including a condemnation of the attack on Israeli civilians on October 7. It also endorses the Palestinian Authority (PA) to take over future responsibility for security and civilian affairs.
- Relating to the British Government’s announced on unilaterally recognising the State of Palestine, Malcolm Shaw KC presented a series of arguments against unilateral recognition He argued:
- Palestine doesn’t meet key Montevideo Convention standards, specifically lacking effective governance and a defined territory, due to internal division between PA and Hamas, and lack of territorial control.
- Widespread recognition by states is politically significant but legally insufficient without UN Security Council approval or clear factual statehood.
- Palestinians have the right to self-determination, but that alone doesn’t override legal thresholds for statehood.
- Allowing declarations of statehood outside accepted criteria and procedures, even under self-determination undermines international legal order.
Looking ahead: The change to now focus on a comprehensive ceasefire plan – rather than a partial deal – will take time, as it requires resolving several difficult issues. These include the ratio and identity of Palestinian terrorists in Israeli jails to be released, the nature and geographical redeployment of the IDF, and the demilitarisation of the Strip.
- The latter is understood to be part of a growing consensus that Hamas must agree to stop repairing / digging new tunnels, to stop the manufacture of missiles and explosives and to stop smuggling weapons under the Philadelphi Corridor from Egypt.
- In light of the failure of the talks, the inner security cabinet will meet later this week to discuss next steps. The IDF has reduced its troop deployment and has long supported a deal. But if the government decides to continue fighting, Chief of Staff Zamir has recommended increasing operations and raids in parts of the Strip where the IDF has not operated so far, such as Gaza City and the refugee camps in the central Gaza Strip. These raids will be evaluated to avoid harming the remaining hostages.
- Defence officials anticipate that Hamas will release more videos of the hostages in captivity in an effort to ratchet up pressure on Israel.


