What’s happened: A body handed over to Israel by the Palestinian Islamic Jihad yesterday was confirmed this morning to be that of Israeli hostage Dror Or from Kibbutz Beeri.
- Dror Or was a 48-year-old cheesemaker and yoga instructor living on the kibbutz with his wife Yonat and two of their young children. On October 7, 2023 terrorists from the Islamic Jihad set fire to their home. The four members of the Or family slipped out the window of their safe room as their house burned and scattered in different directions. Yonat was murdered on the spot. The two children were taken hostage and released later in a ceasefire. Dror’s fate was unknown until May of 2024, when authorities determined based on intelligence that he too had been killed and his body held in Gaza.
- In a statement issued by Kibbutz Beeri, they described Dror Or as an “exemplary family man, a devoted friend, a calm, pleasant and kindhearted man with a gentle sense of humor and high sensitivity towards his surroundings. He loved good food, basketball, trips around the world, yoga exercises and even taught yoga himself.”
- With this handover, there remain two deceased hostages held in Gaza. Sudthisak Rinthalak, a Thai agricultural worker, who was murdered on October 7, 2023 in Kibbutz Beeri. Ran Gvili, an Israeli police officer who rushed to the front lines on October 7 despite being on medical leave due to a surgery on his shoulder. He was abducted after being shot by Hamas terrorists. Before that, he reportedly eliminated 14 terrorists. In January 2024, Israeli authorities informed his family that he had been killed.
- According to the ceasefire which went into effect six weeks ago, Hamas was supposed to hand over all hostages living and dead within 72 hours.
- The IDF continues to clear out tunnels in Rafah. Yesterday six Hamas gunmen were eliminated in one encounter with the IDF.
- In the West Bank, the IDF and the Shin Bet launched a major counterterrorism operation focused on the villages of Tamunn and Tubas, between Nablus and Jenin. Citing unnamed Israeli security officials, Ynet reports that the goal of the operation is “to prevent terrorists from regrouping and evolving into battalion-like formations, similar to the situation that existed in parts of the West Bank until about two years ago.”
- Prime Minister Netanyahu met separately yesterday with both Defence Minister Katz and IDF Chief of General Staff Zamir in an attempt to bring to a close the public dispute the two have had over investigations into the failures on October 7.
Context: Conflicting reports emerged yesterday about Hamas’ grip on power in Gaza and its future plans as the first phase of the ceasefire nears its end.
- The London-based, Saudi-backed Al-Sharq al-Awsat reported that Hamas leaders both inside the Gaza Strip and abroad are considering dissolving their armed wing and reconstituting themselves as a political party, possibly even under the umbrella of the PLO. According to the report, Hamas leaders have raised the possibility in discussions with Qatar, Turkey, and Egypt.
- Israeli defence officials, meanwhile, presented the cabinet with worrying signs of Hamas reestablishing its prewar bases of power in the Strip. In the areas beyond the Yellow Line, there are reports, Hamas has gradually reestablished complete control, deploying police and checkpoints and collecting taxes. In total, 13 out of 25 municipalities have resumed full activity, all under Hamas control.
- On the Israeli side of the Yellow Line, pockets of Hamas gunmen remain holed up in tunnels that the IDF is gradually dismantling. Estimates suggest security sources claiming that hundreds of metres of tunnels have been demolished, together with 15 tunnel shafts and 40 buildings that hid the shafts or served as terrorist bases. Troops quoted in the report say that Hamas gunmen found in the tunnels have two choices: “surrender or death.”
- A feud has been raging at the apex of the Israeli security establishment about responsibility and lesson learning from the October 7, and the extent to which it should be limited to the military and intelligence services.
- Following a military investigation written over the course of seven months by 12 major-generals and brigadier-generals – known as the Turjeman report – (itself an investigation of previous IDF investigations into combat and intelligence failures) Chief of Staff Zamir last week summoned senior officers implicated in the October 7 failures, including many long out of active duty. He informed them that they were being dismissed for their roles in the IDF’s failures to anticipate and properly repel the attack.
- Together with the dismissals, Zamir also announced several new appointments and promotions. Defence Minister Katz intervened to freeze the appointments and asked to revisit the Turjeman report. Mutual leaks ensued, with associates of both men accusing the other of undermining each other’s authority and impugning the other’s motives.
- Yediot Ahronot reported that in the Prime Minister’s orbit there were those who accused Katz of “primary-season tweeting.” Anonymous sources close to Netanyahu say that the Prime Minister regrets appointing Zamir, who has proven to be much more independent than was hoped for.
Looking ahead: With the public spat between Defence Minister Katz and IDF Chief of General Staff Zamir dominating headlines in Israel, Israel Hayom reports that the Prime Minister is considering a cabinet reshuffle that would, among other things, reassign Katz to the Energy Ministry.
- In the reshuffle under consideration, Foreign Minster Gideon Saar would take over at Defence, and Eli Cohen would return to the Foreign Ministry. Katz and Cohen were originally slated to rotate at the Foreign and Energy Ministries, but the firing of Gallant and the rejoining of Saar to the coalition saw both men assume different posts.

