What’s happened: In a voting spree before the Knesset dissolves at the end of the week, the government succeeded in passing two laws that acceded to the demands of the ultra-Orthodox parties.
- On Monday, Basic Law: Torah Study was passed declaring Torah study a “fundamental value” of the Jewish people and the State of Israel. The law passed with 63:52 majority.
- On Tuesday, the Knesset passed a bill into law which will see the ultra-Orthodox deserters exempted for several months from arrest, investigation and enforcement proceedings if they are recognised as yeshiva students. The final vote passed by 58 votes to 45.
- Prime Minister Netanyahu was in the Knesset building but did not attend the vote itself.
- Coalition MKs Sharren Haskel, Yuli Edelstein and Dan Illouz, together with MK Moshe Solomon (Religious Zionist Party), voted against the measure.
- MKs Michal Woldiger and Ofir Sofer of the Religious Zionist Party, as well as Minister Gila Gamliel and MKs Galit Distel Atbaryan and Moshe Passal of the Likud, were present in the Knesset plenum but abstained in the vote.
- Following the approval of the law, Deputy Foreign Minister Sharren Haskel announced her resignation. “It is a law that harms servants and the security of the state, it harms those who have served the state for three years and paid a heavy price,” she said.
Context: The quasi-constitutional recognition of Torah studies was a key demand of the ultra-Orthodox parties, Shas and UTJ, which support the Netanyahu government. The ultra-Orthodox communities say that military service is incompatible with their religious values.
- The issue has been long disputed and is currently one of the most politically divisive issues in Israeli politics, with opponents of the exception calling for more equal sharing of the burden, especially following October 7. Since then almost a thousand soldiers, including reservists, have been killed.
- There are two divergent assessments on the significance of the new law, whose final wording stipulates that “Torah study is a fundamental value in the heritage of the Jewish people and in the State of Israel.”
- Some argue that it is purely symbolic and declarative, especially after all of the other additional sections were removed, including the section that stipulated that the value of Torah study would be weighed on the scales of justice alongside other values.
- Some ultra-Orthodox MK’s consider this an incomparably important law, believing it will have weighty consideration when the High Court next debates the issue.
- That test is likely to come soon. Immediately after the bill was passed, Yisrael Beiteinu petitioned the High Court of Justice, demanding the law be overturned and an interim injunction be issued to halt its implementation. Leader of Yisrael Beiteinu MK Avigdor Liberman said, “The law to freeze the arrest of deserters is one of the most shameful and reckless laws the State of Israel has known since its founding. That same deserter, if he were secular or from the religious Zionist sector, would be arrested and sent to prison. If he is ultra-Orthodox, on the other hand, the government grants him immunity from arrest.”
- Ahead of the vote IDF Chief of Staff Zamir made it clear that he opposed the bill. In a letter addressed to Prime Minister Netanyahu, Zamir said the proposal “provides an incentive for non-reporting for military service….The proposal clearly does not align with the needs of the IDF.” Zamir has repeatedly warned of the need for more manpower in order to sustain the IDF’s current posture across multiple fronts.
- Decriminalising ultra-Orthodox draft deserters is another piece in the puzzle that marred Netanyahu’s government during this Knesset tenure as it saw both Shas and UTJ ministers leaving the cabinet last year in July.
- The other last-minute concession secured by the ultra-Orthodox parties include kashrut supervision bill, which centralises supervision over kosher food certification reversing the previous government opening of the kashrut industry to competition.
- In order to make legislative space for yesterday’s Knesset passage, the government removed the Metropolitan Authorities Law from the agenda. Had it passed, transportation planning powers would have been devolved from the government to local authorities in the Tel Aviv metropolitan area, Jerusalem and Haifa.
Looking ahead: Other highly contentious legislative proposals are expected to reach a vote before the Knesset closes its final session at the end of the week, including legislation to split the role of the Attorney General and the regulatory media bill.
- Under the provisions of the new law which, “recognises the importance of Torah study,” a temporary special arrangement will be made to halt the arrest of yeshiva students whose “vocation is Torah study.” The temporary provision will be valid from the date of the law’s passage until November 30, 2026.
- Relating to these new laws, leader of the Together Party Bennett declared, “The next government will be established on the basis of Zionist parties. Shas and UTJ are anti-Zionist parties. They teach their children, ‘We’ll die and won’t enlist.’ It’s disgraceful that we are bankrolling that.” He added that forming a government along with Deri (Shas) would be a “terrible mistake.. since if you do that you won’t be able to correct anything.”
- Prime Minister Netanyahu is planning to visit the US and meet President Trump, possibly as early as next week.


