What’s happened: The two ambassadors met yesterday with the goal of reaching a peace agreement between the two countries.
- Ahead of the meeting, US Secretary of State Rubio referred to a “historic opportunity” rather than a ceasefire. He spoke of how the talks were about “bringing a permanent end to 20 or 30 years of Hezbollah’s influence in this part of the world and the – not just the damage that it’s inflicted on Israel, the damage that it’s inflicted on the Lebanese people. We have to remember the Lebanese people are victims of Hezbollah. The Lebanese people are victims of Iranian aggression. And this needs to stop.”
- He cautioned that it would take time. “This is a process, not an event.” He spoke of the hope that “we can outline the framework upon which a permanent and lasting peace can be developed so that, as I said, the people of Israel can live in peace, and the people of Lebanon can live not just in peace but the prosperity and security that they deserve.”
- Following the meeting, the three sides issued a joint statement noting that the participants held “productive discussions” on steps “toward launching direct negotiations between Israel and Lebanon.” The United States congratulated the two countries on this historic milestone and expressed its support for further talks, and for the Government of Lebanon’s plans to restore the monopoly of force and to end Iran’s overbearing influence.” The US also “underscored that these negotiations have the potential to unlock significant reconstruction assistance and economic recovery for Lebanon and expand investment opportunities for both countries.”
- After the meeting, Israeli Ambassador to the US Yechiel Leiter said, “The Lebanese government made it very clear that they will no longer be occupied by Hezbollah,” adding, “We are both united in liberating Lebanon from an occupation power dominated by Iran called Hezbollah.”
- Ambassador Leiter revealed that the sides discussed “the long-term vision, where there will be a clearly delineated border between our countries, and where the only reason we’ll need to cross each other’s territory will be in business suits to conduct business, or in bathing suits to go on vacation.”
- At the same time, rocket fire from Hezbollah continues. This morning about 40 rockets were fired into northern Israel.
Context: This symbolic but significant meeting was the first time Israel and Lebanon have held direct talks since 1993.
- For Israel, the talks reflect the doctrine of ‘peace through strength,’ Ambassador Leiter committed to “work tirelessly for tranquility and prosperity for all. Today, we pursue those values for ourselves and especially for our Lebanese neighbours of all ethnic denominations. I commend President Joseph Aoun and his government for not allowing itself to be held hostage to the threats of Hezbollah’s leader. Naim Qassem and Hezbollah belong to the past. We are here for the future. I believe that we can, in good faith, accomplish the following interrelated goals: the complete dismantlement of Hezbollah, the freeing of Lebanon from Iran’s terror proxy, and the achievement of a real, lasting and mutually-celebrated peace for the benefit of our peoples.”
- It is understood that at this point the US aspire to reach a ‘shelf agreement’ that will be ready for implementation once Hezbollah is disarmed.
- It is also notable that France has so far been absent from the process. Given Paris’s historic role in Lebanon and its longstanding political and cultural ties there, this underlines how firmly the talks are currently being driven by Washington.
- Despite the optimism emanating from Washington, fighting in southern Lebanon continued, whist Hezbollah missiles and drone continue to target communities in northern Israel. A security official revealed that still over 50 per cent of Hezbollah attacks are being launched from south of the Litani River, signifying that despite IDF advances on the ground it will take much more work to fully demilitarise southern Lebanon.
- Whilst IDF manoeuvres in southern Lebanon continue, Israeli troops have not advanced further north and have held back from any further escalation. The IDF has not targeted Hezbollah positions in Beirut for almost a week. This is thought to have been done at the request of the US.
- Meanwhile, Hezbollah continue to attack northern Israel. Sirens were sounded throughout the day yesterday in Kiryat Shmona and other northern communities. A drone struck the main entrance to Nahariya.
- The negotiations are a result of US pressure on both sides, aiming to create a political horizon for Lebanon and, mainly, to create conditions to allow for US-Iranian negotiations.The Israeli approach is to negotiate with Lebanon as if there is no Hezbollah, and to fight Hezbollah as if there are no peace negotiations.
- Whilst Iran continues to exercise influence over Lebanon it will be impossible to reach a deal. As an example, despite Lebanon declaring the Iranian ambassador to Lebanon as persona non grata, they have been unable to expel him and he remains holed up in the embassy.
Looking ahead: Despite Israel’s desire to sever the ties between Iran and Lebanon, most analysts believe there can only be progress with Lebanon once the US has resolved their conflict with Iran.
- After this initial meeting the sides are expected to meet again in the next few weeks. It will be noteworthy whether the talks remain at the level of ambassadors or if more senior figures agree to meet. A second indicator of progress will be the inclusion of military officials, cartographers, and national security experts.
